A recent Reuters/Ipsos poll found that 62% of Americans, including a majority of both Democrats and Republicans, said they were less likely to vote for a candidate that goes after companies for their views.
The poll is relevant because of Ron DeSantis’s signing a law that removes Disney’s self-governing authority because of its opposition to Florida’s Don’t Say Gay law. Its results are irrelevant because DeSantis doesn’t care about those who disagree. The move plays well with the base, the only constituency he cares about. The point of the law is that if you disagree with him, you might be next.
In fairness, DeSantis didn’t act alone–both houses of the legislature voted to strip Disney’s self-governing power and sent the bill to DeSantis. In form, it isn’t like power-mad governors (including DeSantis) taking advantage of the Covid to legislate via executive order. But the results are the same–erosion of our freedom.
It’s part of a growing trend at all levels of American government to say how things will be, regardless of the pesky spirit and letter of the Constitution. The trend is currently driven by Republicans, but Democrats have been quick to apply the same equation to support their pet causes.
A new model for subverting the Constitution came with the Texas abortion law. That law allows the (currently) Constitutional right to abortion to remain technically legal, but giving everyone standing to sue anyone who has anything to do with anyone getting an abortion. Earlier this week, Oklahoma legislators doubled down on Texas approach, passing a bill that allows a $10,000 judgement against providers who perform abortions after six weeks.
California Governor Gavin Newsom saw the opportunity to boost his Presidential aspirations by sponsoring a bill in California to allow people to sue gun manufacturers for illegal firearms. If this model’s upheld, other states will find creative ways to use it to form society to the only proper model–the one they want.
None of this is about abortion or Disney or gun rights. It’s about politicians subverting nearly 250 years of governing principles to please their base and punish opponents. Ultimately, it’s about extending government control. Though both side oppose the other’s goals, they’re looking for use cases to borrow the other side’s tactics.
The Florida government’s actions are a brazen attempt to use its power to force a private entity to toe the line when it comes to thought and expression. It’s something North Korean President Kim Jung-un would do if he didn’t have the power to simply have you and your family killed.
If Florida can take punitive measures against Disney for its opposition to political actions, why can’t California or New York take similar actions against any entity that opposes their policies?
If you can sue people for getting an abortion, a right currently guaranteed by Roe v. Wade, why not allow people to sue anyone who helps people hear Joe Rogan be a supposed anti-vaxxer? Or anyone denying climate change? Or failing to stand when the National Anthem is played at a sporting event?
If school boards can ban books because they consider two gay characters to be porn, why can’t other school boards ban the Bible because Lot’s daughters got him drunk and raped him? If Florida can ban math books that are too woke, why can’t school boards in San Francisco ban history books that depict any part of American history as a positive?
If we’re supposed to be the land of the free and the home of the brave, we shouldn’t be trying to find ways around Constitutional freedoms. Our government shouldn’t be using its might against organizations that disagree with its political decisions. And as citizens, we need to be smarter than to cheer their efforts. They aren’t acting in our best interests.
This isn’t about Democrats or Republicans. Republicans are doing most of the damage now, but as The Gavinator showed, Democrats will follow the same playbook when it suits their interests.
Meanwhile our freedoms–which include the right to offend and irritate people who don’t like our stances–are being chipped away. In our collective effort to demonize and own the other side, we don’t realize the damage that’s being done to everyone’s freedoms.