The posts show up on my Facebook feed once every other week or so–usually white letters on a black background. Something to the effect of: Business owners are complaining that workers won’t come back because they make more on unempleyment than working. Maybe if they paid a living wage, that wouldn’t be a problem. The posts assume that business owners are rolling in cash and withhold reasonable pay so they can enrich themselves.
People over profits, donchya know?
In a completely unrelated story, Los Angeles mayor Eric Garcetti is proposing a programe to award 5,000 small businesses $5,000 a piece to help them defray the impact of the Covid on their businesses and try to keep them afloat.
“Your city is going to have your back so you can reopen, hire up, and spread the wealth,” Mayor Garcetti said during his state of the city address.
Camille Perry, who runs bars in Sherman Oaks and Hollywood said the money won’t save her businesses. She’s amassed $90.000 in back rent amid the shutdown. She suggests that the city provide tax breaks to landlords willing to negotiate leases with their tenants.
Another business owner, Atika Enciso, runs a studio called Studio Blo. The pandemic and resulting shutdowns caused her revenue to fall from $165,000 a month to $20,000. She has $80,000 in debt and has changed locations to cut her overhead (and ability to make money).
The article references a survey from WalletHub that says more than 50 million businesses report it’ll take a year or more to return to pre-pandemic sales. In the meantime, many have significant debt. In LA County alone, almost 15,000 businesses closed since the beginning of the pandemic. Half of them will probably never re-open.
Amazon, Google, and other enormous companies aren’t the ones saying they can’t afford to compete with enhanced unemployment benefits. Most of the complainers are small businesses hanging on by a thread, with owners who mortgaged their financial futures just to stay in business. According to a Lending Tree survey from last September, three quarters of small business owners have taken on debt to manage financial losses–and that’s before the shutdowns spurred by the wintertime surge in cases.
In short, most small business owners would love to be in position to pay more than unemp[oyment pays to bring their employees back. But they’re struggling to keep the lights on, let alone taking on the additional overhead of bringing staff back in anticipation of income.
The smug, arrogant pronouncement that these people are somehow greedy and evil for not paying at least $15.00 an hour is condescending and tone deaf. It’s borne of a political bigotry that doesn’t count as bigotry–the vision of small business owners spending their ample spare time in a vault filled with cash, rolling around on it like Demi Moore in Indecent Exposure.
It’s insulting and belittles people whose finances have been decimated by the pandemic, many of them people of color in disadvantaged neighborhoods.
They deserve more than than condemnation masquerading as compassion.